Question
What did the Hague tribunal decide in the Savarkar case in 1911?
On 24 February 1911 a tribunal of the Permanent Court of Arbitration at The Hague decided that Great Britain was not required to return Vinayak Damodar Savarkar to France. The tribunal accepted that there had been an irregularity when he was arrested and handed back to British police at Marseilles on 8 July 1910, but held that no rule of international law obliged Britain to restore him for that reason.
The record
Savarkar had escaped through a porthole of the steamer Morea at Marseilles, swum ashore and been caught by a French maritime gendarme, who returned him to the ship. France argued that he should have been surrendered only through extradition.
France and Great Britain signed the arbitration agreement on 25 October 1910. The tribunal had five members and was presided over by Auguste Beernaert of Belgium.
The charge, and the answer
What critics say. Some point out that the award went against France and gave Savarkar himself no relief.
A prisoner's leap from a porthole made two European powers argue the law of asylum before an international tribunal, and the tribunal itself recorded that his arrest on French soil was irregular. The case carried the cause of Indian freedom into the courts and newspapers of Europe.
Sources
Cite this page
Savarkar Archive. “What did the Hague tribunal decide in the Savarkar case in 1911?.” https://savarkararchive.com/questions/what-did-the-hague-tribunal-decide-in-1911. Accessed [date].
Permanent address: https://savarkararchive.com/questions/what-did-the-hague-tribunal-decide-in-1911