Questions
The questions most often asked about Savarkar, answered from the record.
- Did Savarkar write mercy petitions?
Yes. While held in the Cellular Jail at Port Blair between 1911 and 1921, Savarkar submitted several petitions to the British Government of India asking for release, including petitions dated 14 November 1913 and 30 March 1920 and others in 1911, 1914 and 1917. He was moved to mainland prisons in 1921 and released on 6 January 1924 on condition that he live in Ratnagiri district and stay out of politics. By his own account he petitioned because a prisoner who could get out and work for the country was bound to try, and he asked for the release of all political prisoners, not only himself.
- What did the Hague tribunal decide in the Savarkar case in 1911?
On 24 February 1911 a tribunal of the Permanent Court of Arbitration at The Hague decided that Great Britain was not required to return Vinayak Damodar Savarkar to France. The tribunal accepted that there had been an irregularity when he was arrested and handed back to British police at Marseilles on 8 July 1910, but held that no rule of international law obliged Britain to restore him for that reason.
- Was Savarkar convicted in the Gandhi murder trial?
No. Savarkar was arrested on 5 February 1948 and tried as one of the accused in the Gandhi murder case at the Red Fort in Delhi. On 10 February 1949 the special court, presided over by Judge Atma Charan, acquitted him. Nathuram Godse and Narayan Apte were sentenced to death.
- What is the holy-land test in Hindutva?
The holy-land test is the final condition in Savarkar's definition of a Hindu in Essentials of Hindutva (1923). A Hindu, he writes, is a person who regards the land from the Sindhu to the seas as both fatherland (pitribhumi) and holy land (punyabhumi). People whose holy lands lie outside India, including Muslims and Christians, fall outside the category even where they share ancestry and culture.
- How long was Savarkar in the Cellular Jail?
About ten years. Savarkar was held in the Cellular Jail at Port Blair in the Andaman Islands from July 1911 until May 1921, when he was moved to prisons on the Indian mainland. He was released from prison on 6 January 1924 and then confined to Ratnagiri district until 1937.