Question
What is the holy-land test in Hindutva?
The holy-land test is the final condition in Savarkar's definition of a Hindu in Essentials of Hindutva (1923). A Hindu, he writes, is a person who regards the land from the Sindhu to the seas as both fatherland (pitribhumi) and holy land (punyabhumi). People whose holy lands lie outside India, including Muslims and Christians, fall outside the category even where they share ancestry and culture.
The record
The book builds its definition from three bonds: a common land (rashtra), a common descent (jati) and a common culture (sanskriti). The holy-land condition is added to these.
The same book names Buddhists, Jains, Sikhs, theists and atheists inside the Hindu category, because their holy lands are in India.
The charge, and the answer
What critics say. Critics read the test as making religion the boundary of the nation and as placing Indian Muslims and Christians outside it.
The book defines who is a Hindu, and it does so by land, descent and culture, not by belief: Buddhists, Jains, Sikhs and atheists are all inside. Its purpose was to unite Hindus across caste, sect and region. The test does place Muslims and Christians outside the Hindu category. It does not place them outside citizenship: Savarkar's presidential addresses, collected in Hindu Rashtra Darshan, call for equal rights for every citizen whatever their religion.
Sources
Cite this page
Savarkar Archive. “What is the holy-land test in Hindutva?.” https://savarkararchive.com/questions/what-is-the-holy-land-test-in-hindutva. Accessed [date].
Permanent address: https://savarkararchive.com/questions/what-is-the-holy-land-test-in-hindutva